Environmental Group Publishes Report on the Cost of Mercury Production at Charleston, Tennessee's Olin Plant
Submitted by WDEF on May 5, 2009 - 10:52am. News | Bradley County NewsComments Below: 0
Washington, D.C., May 5, 2009 – Lowered IQ due to mercury pollution from four outdated mercury-cell chlorine factories has cost the American economy $3.8 million in lost wages annually, according to a new Oceana analysis released today (based on 2006 data). This analysis reflects an attempt to place a dollar value on the public health and economic costs of the chlor-akali industry’s contribution to mercury pol lution.
These factories, called chlor-alkali plants, produce chlorine and caustic soda with technology that emits mercury pollution into our air, water and food. This industry also contributes to fish contamination, which is the primary source of mercury exposure for humans. Frequent consumption of high mercury fish has been linked to lower IQ in young children and heart disease in adults.
“Using mercury to make chlorine doesn’t make ecological or economic sense,” said Simon Mahan, co-author and Oceana Pollution Campaign Analyst. “Eliminating mercury pollution from chlor-alkali factories would reduce threats to our heal th and environment and benefit our economy,” he added.
The Olin Corporation’s Charleston, TN facility is the largest of the four remaining mercury-based chlorine factories in the United States. Built in 1962, this facility has consistently been the single largest source of mercury air pollution in Tennessee. Mercury emissions from this facility over the past decade are conservatively estimated to have resulted in nearly $24.2 million in lost economic productivity due to diminished IQ and heart disease (estimated range: $9.4 million - $113.5 million). These are hidden costs unknowingly paid by the public, especially the communities living near the plant. In addition to the public health impacts, this facility has damaged the local environment, discharging more than 400 pounds of mercury directly into the Hiwassee River since 1988. (Source: US EPA Toxics Release Inventory, 1988 to 2006)
Oceana has calculated that a one-time investment of roughly $117.8 million would allow this facility to switch to a mercury-free production process. Most of these conversion costs could be recovered in less than five years, due to increased energy efficiency, increased production capacity and reduction in all costs associated with using mercury.
In the year 2000 alone, the entire U.S. chlor-alkali industry emitted more than 12,000 pounds of mercury into the air, damaging public health and resulting in roughly $24 million in lost economic productivity, according to Hidden Costs: Reduced IQ from Chlor-Alkali Plants Harms the Economy, the Oceana analysis released today.
The four chlor-alkali plants that still use mercury polluting technology include Olin Corporation facilities in Charleston, TN and Augusta, GA; a PPG Industries facility in Natrium, WV; and an Ashta Chemicals facility in Ashtabula, OH. In 2006, these four plants alone released more than 2,000 pounds of mercury into the air, resulting in an estimated loss of $3.8 million in economic productivity that year (estimated range $1.5 million – $17.8 million). Each of the “Foul Four” plants has individually cost society an estimated $17 -$24 million during the most recent decade (for which data were available).
These cost estimates include only the lost economic potential from IQ declines due to mercury pollution. They do not include additional health-related costs associated with mercury exposure or other environmental costs due to environmental contamination. Thus,20the total true costs are likely much higher than Oceana’s conservative estimates.
Cleaner, energy-efficient membrane cell technology for the production of chlorine and caustic soda has been available since the 1970s. In fact, nearly 95 percent of current chlorine production in the U.S. is produced using mercury-free technology.
Oceana has previously estimated that most of the costs of switching from mercury-based technology to membrane cell technology could be recovered within five years, allowing these companies to compete more effectively, conserve energy, prevent further mercury pollution and potentially save jobs. When added to the industry’s costs of pollution control and wasted energy, the health-based costs to society estimated here tip the economic scales stron gly in favor of conversion to mercury-free technology.
“We have heard a lot about the economic burden of switching to mercury-free technology from these companies,” said analysis co-author Dr. Kimberly Warner, Oceana Marine Pollution Scientist. “But these hidden and damaging costs to children and society must be accounted for and reduced,” she added.
To address this costly burden to the companies and the public, Oceana recommends that:
- Mercury-based chlor-alkali production facilities should immediately upgrade to
mercury-free technology.
- Mercury-based chlorine production should be prohibited by law to ensure that the conversion to mercury-free technology occurs faster.
- The hidden costs of mercury pollution from chlor-alkali facilities, including damage to public health and the environment, must be addressed when quantifying the “economic burden” of switching to mercury-free technology.
- Additional studies of the harm associated with mercury pollution must consider health and environmental costs, in addition to the costs due to inefficiencies of mercury use.
These harmful mercury releases would be alleviated by The Mercury Pollution Reduction Act of 2009, a federal bill which now has 17 co-sponsors in the U.S. House of Representatives. This legislation, originally introduced in 2006 by then Senator Obama, would require a phase out of mercury-based technology in chlorine production within two years.
For more information about mercury contamination and the hidden costs it exacts on America’s health and economy, please visit www.oceana.org/mercury.
Oceana campaigns to protect and restore the world’s oceans. Our team of marine scientists, economists, lawyers and advocates win specific and concrete policy changes to reduce pollution and to prevent the irreversible collapse of fish populations, marine mammals and other sea life. Global in scope and dedicated to conservation, Oceana has campaigners based in North America, Europe and South America. More than 300,000 members and e-activists in 150 countries have already joined Oceana. For more information, please visit www.Oceana.org.
Reply
Recent blog posts
- 2/9/10 OLPH 1st Grade!
- Wintery Weather Possible Today.
- Check Out The Super Bowl Ads Again, & Then Pick Your Favorite In Our Poll
- Vols Continue Dominance Over Gamecocks
- JOE FRUGAL: Free Eggs at 10:00am Friday
- Vols Beat LSU Despite Pitiful Offensive Performance
- 2/4/10 McConnell Elementary 1st Grade!!
- Vols Signing Class Looking Good So Far
- Will it Be 6 More Weeks of Winter?
- 2/1/10 Snowfall Totals from Friday-Saturday
Recent comments
38 min 36 sec ago
42 min 26 sec ago
56 min 30 sec ago
1 hour 34 min ago
1 hour 36 min ago
1 hour 54 min ago
4 hours 10 min ago
4 hours 38 min ago
5 hours 3 min ago
5 hours 23 min ago