The city should pay for all damages to the building and all the loses that Ash has encounted, including loss of business, and income from the rental apartments and store. It is my belief the city should also have to reimbruse Ash for all cleaning and pumping of the sewage. Had the city came out in October when Ash asked them to, this would not be an issue seven months later. Ash would not have had to deal with all the losses he has suffered. I also believe Ash should be entitled to monies for his suffering,(and believe me Ash suffered! just think about it!).