Federal judge dismisses inmate death lawsuit against Hamilton County and former sheriff
MGN
HAMILTON COUNTY, Tenn. (WDEF) — A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed by the estate of a former inmate against Hamilton County and its former sheriff.
On Wednesday, August 27, 2025, U.S. District Court Judge Charles E. Atchley Jr. ruled in favor of Hamilton County and former Sheriff Jim Hammond, granting their motion for summary judgment.
The court dismissed the case with prejudice, ending the legal dispute.
The lawsuit, filed in August 2023 by Amy Burt, on behalf of Timothy Burt, alleged constitutional violations.
Burt’s estate claimed the Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office (HCSO) failed to train staff properly and ignored the inmate’s medical needs, resulting in his death.
Judge Atchley determined the HCSO’s policies complied with Tennessee state law.
He also found no evidence proving staff training was lacking or that a pattern of rights violations existed.
In a statement following the ruling, current Hamilton County Sheriff Austin Garrett said the court’s decision affirms the jail’s commitment to safety and legal compliance.
“The court has reviewed the facts before it and granted the County’s motion for summary judgment, dismissing the plaintiff’s suit, and affirming that the Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office is providing the safest facility possible for the inmates in our custody. Your Sheriff’s Office will continue to focus on leading the way by providing the highest level of law enforcement and corrections services available to our citizens, including safeguarding their well-being and most importantly, their Constitutional rights. While the court’s ruling supports the work being done at the Hamilton County Jail, we also recognize that any loss of life is tragic, and our thoughts remain with the family and loved ones affected by the death of Mr. Burt.”
-Austin Garrett, Hamilton County Sheriff
With the case now closed, officials say they remain committed to upholding constitutional protections and ensuring safe conditions for all inmates in county custody.
